Make your own free website on Tripod.com

Legendary Joan Crawford

Home | Films | Biography | Photos | Ask Casey | Radio Days | Joan A to Z | Lucille Le Sueur Name Contest | Joan's Homes | Letters | Collecting Joan | Boutique | Links | News | About Me / Fans

"The Story of Esther Costello"

costello.jpg

"This was my last really top picture, and frankly, if I think I deserved an Oscar for "Mildred Pierce" I deserved two for "Esther Costello."~Joan Crawford

"The Story of Esther Costello" 1957


Cast: Joan Crawford ~Rossano Brazzi~Heather Sears~Lee Patterson~Ron Randell~Fay Compton~John Loder~Denis O'Dea~Sidney James~Bessie Love~Robert Ayers~Maureen Delaney~Harry Hutchinson~Tony Quinn~Janina Faye~Estelle Brody~June Clyde~Sally Smith~Diana Day~Megs Jenkins~Andrew Cruikshank~Victor Rietti~Sheila Manahan.

Director & Producer: David Miller

Costumes by Jean Louis

Box Office Figures for "The Story of Esther Costello":

Top Grossing Film Position: Ranked #89 out of 109 films.

Gross Rentals: $1,100,000.


If you have seen this movie, please write a review below. Once your review is submitted, I will post the review below. Thank you for your review on this film.

Your Email Address:
How many stars would you give this film? Four being the best.
Your review/thoughts on "The Story of Esther Costello":
  

histeph.jpg

Reviews


Reviewer: tommary1962

Review: Based on the book by Nicholas Monsarrat, Esther Costello is (as has been stated elsewhere) part "Miracle Worker" and part "Elmer Gantry", although Esther Costello predates both. Although not without some unrealistic moments (the problem with nearly every film ever made), the film most certainly captures some of the reality of the life of a blind person and of charity huckstering very well.

Those people who are knowledgeable about the blind always rate this film very highly, sometimes more so that the more famous "Miracle Worker," which some consider overwrought and not very accurate despite being based on a true story. Esther Costello was well researched, with the scenes at the school and the Braille being very accurate (Crawford learned Braille in order to present this aspect accurately). Although condensed, it is clear that Esther's learning took place over a period of many months, perhaps years (one has to use some logic here, if not, it would appear that she learns in a matter of days!). Another sadly true aspect of the film is her rape. Many times I have listened to stories about the lives of blind woman and women with other disabilities who have been taken advantage of by parents or relatives, schoolmates, and spouses. In 1956 when the film was made, a rape scene was all but unheard of. Although it appears somewhat heavy handed today, the scene where the French doors blow open to let a torrent of rain into the room does not, in my opinion, undermine the seriousness of the film as a whole. Despite what some rather idiotic people have stated elsewhere, it is not the rape itself that brings Esther back her sight and speech, it is the great shock of the violence; a violence even greater than the accident which initially made her blind and mute.

Some claim the film lacks credibility (this is often the case with Possessed (1947). People cannot imagine a woman going back to a man like Brazzi. However, very often women (and men) go back again and again to unhealthy relationships, and often leave on bad relationship only to fall into another equally corrosive one.

Crawford and Sears handled their roles exceedingly well. Sears received a BFTA nomination for Best Actress, and Crawford a special citation for her contribution in the film and one for her career as a whole.

While I agree that more emphasis on social commentary (making the film more of a message movie and less of a melodrama) and less on melodrama would have been welcome, Esther Costello's off-beat and interesting tone make for some great moments and set the film above some of Crawford's other 1950's films (Female on the Beach, Queen Bee, Damned Don't Cry and Goodbye My Fancy).

ester.jpg

Reviewer: writerdonna7

Stars: Three and a half out of four stars

Review: "The Story of Esther Costello" holds one of Joan Crawford's finest latter day performances and demonstrates how criminally she was underrated and mishandled throughout much of her career by being handed substandard scripts when, given the chance to showcase her talent properly, she was a very fine actress indeed. The film begins in Ireland when a little girl, Esther Costello (Janina Faye), is left blind, deaf and dumb after accidentally setting off explosives in a root cellar. When a wealthy American socialite Margaret Landi (Crawford) visits Ireland on vacation and runs across Esther, now a young woman (played by Heather Sears), unkempt and crawling around like a wild animal, she is horrified by such neglect and is convinced ultimately to take the girl under her care. Working with Esther to learn how to communicate simple needs, Margaret succeeds in making breakthroughs and later sets up a charitable foundation to raise money for further research and aid for the blind. Margaret's wild success in this fund-raising enterprise attracts the attention of her husband Carlo (Rosanno Brazzi) from whom she is separated. Carlo insinuates his way back into Margaret's life and love, but shortly it becomes clear that his motives are not sincere. Not only is he in league to squander and embezzle funds from Margaret's charitable organization, but he is also taking more than fatherly notice to the shapely, young Esther.

Although this is a fine drama with overall strong and even stellar performances, there are a few implausibilities and some dubious choices in the script, none of which sink the film however. For instance, it is questionable whether Esther could have survived the magnitude of the explosion that opened the film, rather than merely being left blind, deaf and dumb. There is also a scene in which Margaret discovers Carlo intently watching Esther undressing from another room, unaware that Margaret has returned, and Margaret angrily wraps Esther in a towel and shakes her, saying, "You little fool!" Esther is left shaken and bewildered by this sudden rage on the part of her benefactress, and afterwards Margaret begs Carlo tearfully to go away with her alone and abandon the foundation. She wants to also get Esther out of the picture by placing her in college. This seems cold and out of character on the part of the benevolent Margaret. She seems far too competent and confident a woman to be reduced to such desperation and even cruelty by a man she had already separated from once. The ending is also an unfortunate misstep, again allowing Esther to destroy herself rather than simply own up to the truth and place the blame where it belongs when confronted by Esther's boyfriend. Yet somehow the integrity of the performances and the serious issues raised by the script, including the corruptible nature of charitable foundations, overcome any far-fetched film contrivances and keep things believable. Only the ending truly disappoints.

Crawford is amazing as Margaret Landi. In the opening sequences, she is almost too sweet and benevolent yet when Rosanno Brazzi enters the scene, her performance takes off. The scene where Margaret first notices Carlo's designs on Esther is devastating. Crawford proves herself to be at the peak of a mature and considerable talent. She hits all the right notes, as the saying goes, and allows the action to pack a punch as a result of her believability. This is one of her performances that surely warranted an Oscar. Heather Sears is fine as the young girl and Rosanno Brazzi is well cast as the husband, suave and handsome enough to make a great oily manipulator. But Crawford is the best of them all. She also looks terrific, her charm and charisma right on the money for fundraising success.

It's too bad the ending wasn't worthy of the actress and the character both. Overall, a fine drama, a story about a wild blind child and her teacher like "The Miracle Worker" but with its own separate and powerful identity.

easter.jpg

~~CLICK ON THE YELLOW STARS BELOW TO VOTE FOR THIS SITE!~~

p4stars.gif

Limitations on exclusive rights: Fair use

Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include;

(1) the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;

(2) the nature of the copyrighted work;

(3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and

(4) the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.

The fact that a work is unpublished shall not itself bar a finding of fair use if such finding is made upon consideration of all the above factors.

joan crawford picture joan crawford mommie dearest joan crawford biography joan crawford movie bio

<!--Begin SiteStats Code Dec , 38--><STYLE>.ivanC11654435781495{position:absolute;visibility:hidden;}</STYLE><DIV CLASS=ivanC11654435781495 ID=ivanI11654435781495><A HREF=http://freestats.com CLASS=ivanL_FR TARGET=_blank>FREE hit counter and Internet traffic statistics from freestats.com</A></DIV><script language='JavaScript' src='http://joancrawford.freestats.com/cgi-bin/sitestats.gif/script/11654435781495'></script><noscript><a href='http://joancrawford.freestats.com/cgi-bin/sitestats.gif/map'><img src='http://joancrawford.freestats.com/cgi-bin/sitestats.gif/img' border=0></a></noscript><!--End SiteStats Code-->

<html>
<body>

Page Content

<!-- Start of StatCounter Code -->
<script type="text/javascript">
var sc_project=2846823;
var sc_invisible=0;
var sc_partition=29;
var sc_security="e6c0de95";
</script>

<script type="text/javascript" src="http://www.statcounter.com/counter/counter_xhtml.js"></script><noscript><div class="statcounter"><a class="statcounter" href="http://www.statcounter.com/"><img class="statcounter" src="http://c30.statcounter.com/2846823/0/e6c0de95/0/" alt="counter create hit" /></a></div></noscript>
<!-- End of StatCounter Code -->

<body>
<html>